Learn to Discern Criticism and Praise

by Marcia Malzahn | Devotions for Working Women

Ecclesiastes 7:5 (NLT)

It is better to be criticized by a wise person than to be praised by a fool!


Taking criticism is difficult, especially when we have worked very hard on some project and we are proud of our results. However, we can’t grow without criticism. How do we improve if nobody dares to tell us anything because they know what our reaction will be? The key is to know who the person criticizing you is. If it’s coming from a wise person, receive the criticism and make the appropriate changes.

If it’s coming from a person you don’t trust or has the reputation of being a fool, then disregard it. The question is, how do we know what to receive, what to disregard, who is wise, and who is a fool? Sometimes we will know right away just by knowing the source, the person who criticized us. Other times, we will have to take the criticism to the Lord and ask Him to help us discern its validity.

We need to always be open for correction, especially when it comes from the Lord. He knows how to deal with each one of us without hurting us. Sometimes He uses people close to us to speak into our lives so we can improve. On the other hand, receiving praise is easy. We may receive praises from fools or people who say things to gain favor with us, not because they mean it.

We must watch out for those praises and not take them too seriously. Verse 7 says, “Extortion turns wise people into fools, and bribes corrupt the heart.” We have to treat praises the same way we do criticism. We take them to the Lord to help us discern and to protect us from being hurt from criticism or becoming proud from praise.

Source: Devotions for Working Women by Marcia Malzahn.
Excerpt permission granted by Marcia Malzahn.

Website |  More posts

Marcia Malzahn (Marci) was born in Nicaragua, Central America. In 1979 she left Nicaragua due to a revolution and moved to the Dominican Republic and lived there for seven years. Marcia moved to Minnesota in 1986 and started a career in banking with Marquette Banks that continued for the next thirteen years in the areas of Cash Management, Private Banking, and Retail Banking. In 1995 Marcia became the first Online Banking Specialist in the Twin Cities.

In 1999, she moved to the IT field and started working for Living Word Christian Center (LWCC), a non-profit 501(c)3 organization. At LWCC, she held the positions of Y2K Project Manager, Director of IT, Associate in charge of Finance, Human Resources and IT, and was Corporate Assistant Secretary of the Board. She managed a budget of $31.5MM and 28 employees.

In January 2005, Marcia moved back to the banking field and helped start a new bank in Edina, MN, Tradition Capital Bank, now at over $400 million in assets. From 2005 to 2013, Marcia was the Executive Vice President, Chief Operating Officer, and Chief Financial Officer of the bank. In January, 2014, Marcia’s role changed to EVP/COO and was promoted to Chief Risk Officer. Marcia was also the Corporate Secretary of the bank’s Board and of the holding company’s Board.

In October 2014, Marcia started her own bank consulting firm, Malzahn Strategic, focusing on Strategic Planning, Enterprise Risk Management, and Talent Management for community banks. Marcia is also a public speaker and speaks on motivational/inspirational/leadership topics as well as banking topics such as Enterprise Risk Management. She holds an Associates of Arts degree from North Hennepin Community College and graduated with a B.A. in Business Management from Bethel University. Marcia also graduated from the Graduate School of Banking in Madison, WI.

Marcia is involved in the community. She was a member of Financial Women International for sixteen years and held several board positions including president of the local group and of the District. She is a member of the Minnesota Women Economic Roundtable and served as treasurer for two years. Marcia is also chair of the Board of Big Brothers Big Sisters of the Greater Twin Cities. Marcia has also volunteered in other organizations including Matter, Pulse Movement, Opportunity International, Way to Grow, Feed My Starving Children, HopeKids, Meals on Wheels, and Farmers Market Youth Project.

Marcia was the recipient of many awards including:
• 25 On The Rise award given by the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce in December, 2005.
• Forty Under 40 award given by the Minneapolis/St. Paul Business Journal in May, 2006
• Virginia D. H. Furman Outstanding Woman of the Year award from Financial Women International in September, 2006
• Top Women in Finance award from Finance and Commerce Newspaper in November, 2008
• Outstanding Women in Banking award given by the North Western Financial Review magazine in November, 2009

Marcia is the author of her book Devotions for Working Women – A Daily Inspiration to Live a Successful and Balanced Life published in 2006. Marcia published her second book The Fire Within – Connect Your Gifts with Your Calling in October 2015. Marcia and her husband Tim live in Minnesota and have two children: Nicole and Patrick. Marcia enjoys spending time with her family, working out, singing, writing, and public speaking.

Related Resources